Size and Scope of the Interagency Investigative Tool Worry Civil LibertariansThe Justice Department is building a
massive database that allows state and local police officers around the
country to search millions of case files from the FBI, Drug Enforcement
Administration and other federal law enforcement agencies, according to
Justice officials. The system, known as "OneDOJ," already holds
approximately 1 million case records and is projected to triple in size
over the next three years, Justice officials said. The files include
investigative reports, criminal-history information, details of
offenses, and the names, addresses and other information of criminal
suspects or targets, officials said. [...] But civil-liberties and privacy advocates say the scale and contents
of such a database raise immediate privacy and civil rights concerns,
in part because tens of thousands of local police officers could gain
access to personal details about people who have not been arrested or
charged with crimes. The little-noticed program has been coming
together over the past year and a half. It already is in use in pilot
projects with local police in Seattle, San Diego and a handful of other
areas, officials said. About 150 separate police agencies have access,
officials said. But in a memorandum sent last week to the FBI,
U.S. attorneys and other senior Justice officials, Deputy Attorney
General Paul J. McNulty announced that the program will be expanded
immediately to 15 additional regions and that federal authorities will
"accelerate . . . efforts to share information from both open and
closed cases." Eventually, the department hopes, the database
will be a central mechanism for sharing federal law enforcement
information with local and state investigators, who now run checks
individually, and often manually, with Justice's five main law
enforcement agencies: the FBI, the DEA, the U.S. Marshals Service, the
Bureau of Prisons and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and
Explosives. Within three years, officials said, about 750 law enforcement agencies nationwide will have access. [...] Barry Steinhardt, director of the Technology and Liberty Project at the
American Civil Liberties Union, said the main problem is one of
"garbage in, garbage out," because case files frequently include
erroneous or unproved allegations. "Raw police files or FBI reports can never be verified and can never
be corrected," Steinhardt said. "That is a problem with even more
formal and controlled systems. The idea that they're creating another
whole system that is going to be full of inaccurate information is just
chilling." Steinhardt noted that in 2003, the FBI announced that
it would no longer meet the Privacy Act's accuracy requirements for the
National Crime Information Center, its main criminal-background-check
database, which is used by 80,000 law enforcement agencies across the
country.
11:54:28 PM PermaLink /
|