Privacy Digest

News that can impact your privacy.
Login/Register
What is OpenID?
  • Log in using OpenID
  • Cancel OpenID login
  • Create new account
  • Request new password
Home Blogs MacRonin's blog
    • FAQ
    • Wishlists
    • Contact
    • Categories/RSS

Bookmark Us

Bookmark Privacy Digest 
Bookmark This Page 

Syndicate

Syndicate content
more

Advertisements

Tracking System
Tracking System
Private Detectives
Quality Security Services in California
Fleet Management
Hosting

Popular content

Last viewed:

  • Europe Looms as Major Battleground for Google
  • Windows Vista Security: Pros and Cons, Third Party Solutions Still Needed
  • Will the FTC Target EULAs Next?
  • Judge restricts online reporting of case - No names on the web
  • DNS Exploit in the Wild -- Update: 2nd More Serious Exploit Released
  • Mission: Possible, Protect Harvard from the RIAA (Crimson Op-Ed)
  • Security Now 86: Cross Site Scripting Part II

tags in Topics

Activists Alert Anonymity Companies Congress Copyright Court (US) Databases Data Mining Editorial EFF Entertainment Exploits Fourth Amendment Government Hmmm ID Infrastructure Law Enforcement Laws Politics Privacy Remember Reports Rights Security Spin Zone Surveillance Telecommunications Tracking
more tags

View blog authority
Congressional Research
Broadcast Flag

Copying as Search and Seizure

Submitted by MacRonin on November 18, 2009 - 4:33pm
  • Activists
  • Court (US)
  • Editorial
  • FBI - Federal Bureau Of Investigation
  • Fourth Amendment
  • Government
  • Hmmm
  • Law Enforcement
  • Legal
  • Rights
  • Washington

Copying as Search and Seizure: Via CYB3RCRIM3 blog.

In other posts, I’ve argued that copying data is a “seizure” under the 4th Amendment.

As I explained in those posts, if copying is a 4th Amendment seizure, law enforcement officers must either get a warrant authorizing the seizure or be able to use one of the exceptions to the warrant requirement to justify copying the data. As I noted, if copying data is neither a search nor a seizure, law enforcement officers can copy data without satisfying any of the 4th Amendment’s requirements.

In the earlier posts I explained why I think copying is a seizure, not a search. I also noted that the issue hasn’t come up much; the only reported decision explicitly addressing it is U.S. v. Gorshkov, 2001 WL 1024026 (U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington 2001), which I discussed in an earlier post.

The Gorshkov court held that FBI agents’ copying data Gorshkov had stored on a server

was not a seizure under the Fourth Amendment because it did not interfere with Defendant's or anyone else's possessory interest in the data. The data remained intact and unaltered. It remained accessible to Defendant and any co-conspirators or partners with whom he had shared access. The copying of the data had absolutely no impact on his possessory rights.Therefore it was not a seizure under the Fourth Amendment. . . .

U.S. v. Gorshkov, supra. I disagree. As I’ve explained in earlier posts, I think copying involves a transfer of some quantum of the value or utility of property, such as data, and therefore constitutes a 4th Amendment seizure.

Read Original Article:(Via CYB3RCRIM3 blog.)

Bookmark/Search this post with:
  • Twitter Twitter
  • Digg Digg
  • StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
  • Technorati Technorati
  • del.icio.us del.icio.us
  • Facebook Facebook
  • Furl Furl
  • LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Yahoo Yahoo
  • MacRonin's blog
  • Add new comment

Recent blog posts

  • FBI Hoaxes Boost Online Fraud
  • NetFlix Cancels Recommendation Contest After Privacy Lawsuit
  • Advertising - Instant Ads Set the Pace on the Web
  • Best Practices for Government Datasets: Wrap-Up
  • TJX Hacking Conspirator Gets 4 Years
  • The Beginning of the End of Data Retention
  • Wanted: Trust Detector
  • Wikibooks Cryptography Textbook
  • Feds: TSA Worker Tried to Sabotage Terror Database
  • Hi-tech governments growing keener on snooping, says report
more

Performancing Metrics

Compilation © Copyright 1997-2010 Paul Hardwick, with Web Hosting provided by MacRonin.com.