OpEd
Opinion and editorial pieces about privacy, civil rights and more.

 


















Subscribe to "OpEd" in Radio UserLand.

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.

 

 

  Monday, February 19, 2007


Late in the afternoon of Jan. 16, a SWAT team from the Fulton County Sheriff's Office, backed up by officers from the Clayton County Sheriff's Office and the local police department, along with a few drug-sniffing dogs, burst into a unmarked recording studio on a short, quiet street in an industrial neighborhood near the Georgia Dome in Atlanta. The officers entered with their guns drawn; the local police chief said later that they were "prepared for the worst." They had come to serve a warrant for the arrest of the studio's owners on the grounds that they had violated the state's Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations law, or RICO, a charge often used to lock up people who make a business of selling drugs or breaking people's arms to extort money. The officers confiscated recording equipment, cars, computers and bank statements along with more than 25,000 music CDs. Two of the three owners of the studio, Tyree Simmons, who is 28, and Donald Cannon, who is 27, were arrested and held overnight in the Fulton County jail. Eight employees, mostly interns from local colleges, were briefly detained as well.

Later that night, a reporter for the local Fox TV station, Stacey Elgin, delivered a report on the raid from the darkened street in front of the studio. She announced that the owners of the studio, known professionally as DJ Drama and DJ Don Cannon, were arrested for making "illegal CDs." The report cut to an interview with Matthew Kilgo, an official with the Recording Industry Association of America, who was involved in the raid. The R.I.A.A., a trade and lobbying group that represents the major American record labels, works closely with the Department of Justice and local police departments to crack down on illegal downloading and music piracy, which most record-company executives see as a dire threat to their business.

Kilgo works in the R.I.A.A.'s Atlanta office, and in the weeks before the raid, the local police chief said, R.I.A.A. investigators helped the police collect evidence and conduct surveillance at the studio. Kilgo consulted with the R.I.A.A.'s national headquarters in advance of the raid, and after the raid, a team of men wearing R.I.A.A. jackets was responsible for boxing the CDs and carting them to a warehouse for examination.


5:02:09 PM    

Fred Amoroso is the CEO of Macrovision, a company that earns its keep by inventing and maintaining DRM systems and charging Hollywood an arm and a leg for it. The two are a good match, insofar as they both greatly fear technology, and both spin amazing tales to bolster their views.

In the wake of Steve Jobs' fashionably-late missive against DRM, Amoroso has crafted a response that seeks to convince us all that DRM is not only needed, it's actually a fantastic "enabler" that consumers should embrace. He focuses on four arguments:

  • DRM is broader than just music
  • DRM increases, not decreases consumer value
  • DRM will increase electronic distribution
  • DRM needs to be interoperable and open

DRM is indeed broader than music, and it's no surprise that the CEO of a DRM-producing company would like to see DRM put on everything possible, particularly movies, music, games and software. The reasons why we should want this are ridiculous.


4:30:00 PM    


Click here to visit the Radio UserLand website. © Copyright 2007 Paul Hardwick.
Last update: 3/4/07; 9:03:57 AM.

February 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28      
Jan   Mar